• Latest
  • Trending
  • All

The school hostage massacre that exposed Putin’s weakness

September 3, 2024

Trump may release US-Iran deal before Friday, Vance says

June 16, 2026

What is Helium-3 and could we get it from the moon?

June 16, 2026

Polls open on Thursday for the Makerfield by-election

June 16, 2026

Social media ban – bold and blunt, but no silver bullet

June 16, 2026

Alessio Dionisi: Watford appoint Italian as new head coach

June 15, 2026

Fox to buy Roku streaming firm in $22bn deal

June 15, 2026

Why I sold my business to my staff

June 15, 2026

The costs and challenges facing the 2026 World Cup

June 15, 2026

New microplastics research examines River Thames pollution

June 15, 2026

Reform pledges new tax on hiring foreign workers

June 15, 2026

Gang guilty of organised crime in £4m cocaine and dirty money ring

June 15, 2026

Pensioner suffocated neighbour and recorded his dying words, court told

June 15, 2026
News
  • Login
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Worklife
  • Travel
  • Reel
  • Future
  • More
Tuesday, June 16, 2026
No Result
View All Result

NEWS

3 °c
London
8 ° Wed
9 ° Thu
11 ° Fri
13 ° Sat
  • Home
  • Video
  • World
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • Latin America
    • Middle East
    • US & Canada

    World Cup 2026: Nestory Irankunda – the refugee who quit Bayern to make Australia history

    Trump and thousands of others watch UFC fight on White House lawn

    South African TV star arrested after allegedly kidnapping man in girlfriend dispute

    Australia demands answers after girl taken hostage is shot dead by Pakistan police

    Norwegian crown princess's son found guilty of two counts of rape

    US musician Oliver Tree dies in helicopter collision in Brazil

    US and Iran agree deal to end war as Trump says Strait of Hormuz to reopen

    'Boyfriend duties call,' Trudeau says after skipping Canada match to watch Perry

    Clinical Australia upset Turkey in World Cup opener

  • UK
    • All
    • England
    • N. Ireland
    • Politics
    • Scotland
    • Wales

    Polls open on Thursday for the Makerfield by-election

    Alessio Dionisi: Watford appoint Italian as new head coach

    Reform pledges new tax on hiring foreign workers

    Gang guilty of organised crime in £4m cocaine and dirty money ring

    Pensioner suffocated neighbour and recorded his dying words, court told

    Reports nurses told by police to show ID to masked men during trouble – O'Neill

    Starmer set to ban under-16s from major social media platforms

    Hamilton says Barcelona win beyond wildest dreams

    Sinkholes near Purley bridge halt Gatwick trains

  • Business
    • All
    • Companies
    • Connected World
    • Economy
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Global Trade
    • Technology of Business

    What is Helium-3 and could we get it from the moon?

    Fox to buy Roku streaming firm in $22bn deal

    Why I sold my business to my staff

    Oil prices slide after Pakistan announces deal between US and Iran

    UK electric car sales target set to be weakened

    Why the US economy keeps defying the odds

    Teen plans to leave uni 'debt free' after making £35,000 selling vintage football shirts

    Beauty Pie LED mask ad banned over misleading anti-wrinkle claim

    Elon Musk becomes world's first trillionaire as SpaceX soars in stock market debut

  • Tech
  • Entertainment & Arts

    Meghan hits red carpet at Power of Women in Hollywood

    Margot Robbie unable to speak at Saltburn premiere

    Barbra Streisand: Siri can now pronounce my name

    Wes Anderson’s The Grand Budapest Hotel inspires cinema’s look

    Taylor Swift/ Travis Kelce romance reaches White House

    The Killers booed at Georgia concert after inviting Russian fan on stage

    Watch: Memorable moments from Parkinson's star-studded show

    Tom Jones: Neighbour surprised to find singer in flat below

    Black Country Folk Festival showcases local musicians

    Watch: Australians set new world record with Tina Turner dance

  • Science
  • Health
  • In Pictures
  • Reality Check
  • Have your say
  • More
    • Newsbeat
    • Long Reads

NEWS

No Result
View All Result
Home World Europe

The school hostage massacre that exposed Putin’s weakness

September 3, 2024
in Europe
11 min read
251 2
0
492
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Getty Images A woman weeps as she looks at photos of the victims killed in the school sports hall in BeslanGetty Images

The day Beslan began burying its dead, there were so many cars loaded with coffins that there was gridlock on the road to the cemetery.

In the small Caucasus town, everyone had lost a relative or knew someone killed in the siege of School No. 1.

Launched by heavily armed militants, mainly from Chechnya, the terror attack lasted three days.

Three hundred and thirty-four people died; 186 of them were children.

It’s 20 years today since the siege ended suddenly in devastating explosions, but I can still hear the wailing of Beslan’s mothers; the grief that rolled over the town in waves.

I can picture the white open coffin of 11-year-old Alina, laid out in her front yard with her dolls placed carefully beside her.

And I will always remember Rima, who spent three days crammed into the stifling school gym with her grandchildren and hundreds of other hostages, bombs strung from the basketball hoops above them.

Back then, she confessed that she was ashamed to have survived.

As she and her grandchildren ran for the exit, under fire, they had to climb over the dead body of a small boy.

“God forgive us for that,” Rima begged, through streams of tears.

Getty Images Vladimir Putin visits the destroyed school No 1 in Beslan in August 2024Getty Images

Vladimir Putin visited the destroyed school on 20 August 2024

Early lessons in Putinism

In 2004, the suffering of Beslan was felt all over Russia and resonated all over the world.

First and foremost, the tragedy was caused by the dozens of men and women who stormed the school, firing in the air and taking hundreds of petrified people hostage.

They had rounded up mothers with babies and balloons, and little girls with big white bows in their hair. Whole families who had been celebrating the first day back to school. The militants stuffed the gym with explosives and began executing the male hostages.

That summer, Vladimir Putin’s brutal war against separatists in Chechnya – launched four years earlier – had already burst beyond the borders of the southern Russian republic.

The day before the Beslan siege, 10 people were killed when a Chechen woman blew herself up outside a Moscow metro station. Before that, suicide bombers blew two planes from the sky and there was a deadly attack on a music festival.

But for two decades now there have been persistent, troubling questions about how Mr Putin and his officials handled the attack on Beslan in their determination not to “give in” to terrorists.

Did they even try to negotiate?

Why claim the attackers made no political demands when they had called for Russian troops to pull out of Chechnya?

Could more children have been freed?

Most critically, why did rescuers fire from tanks and use flamethrowers when there were still hundreds of hostages inside the school?

To many, the siege of Beslan offered crucial early lessons in Putinism, including that he would spare nothing and no one to crush those who challenged him.

Getty Images The destroyed school in BeslanGetty Images

The destroyed school in Beslan

Image protection

It took 20 years for Mr Putin to visit the ruins of School No. 1.

Even then, he didn’t join the anniversary events with the families. He only travelled there two weeks ago, alone.

A few shattered walls of the school were left standing as a memorial, eventually encased in a gold-tinted shroud and hung with framed photographs of the dead.

There, in the middle of the gym where the hostages were held, Mr Putin placed flowers beneath a wooden cross.

For most world leaders, it would be unfathomable not to have visited this spot before. It was Russia’s deadliest ever terror attack. But Mr Putin has always preferred to be filmed in a fighter jet or flanked by soldiers.

The graves of children that he couldn’t save do nothing for his action man image.

In fact, he had been to Beslan before, but barely noticed.

Right after the siege collapsed, he flew in late at night to visit a hospital under cover of darkness. He told Beslan that all Russia was mourning with them but by sunrise he was gone.

“He came far too late,” I remember hearing back then, from grieving families. “He should have stayed with us.”

But President Putin didn’t dare.

Four years earlier, a previous encounter with grieving women had scarred and scared him. When the Kursk submarine sank in 2000 it took him five days to break off his holiday and by the time he met the relatives, they tore shreds off him.

So Mr Putin began making the carefully-choreographed meeting a hallmark of his presidency. Only small, pre-vetted crowds. Everything under control.

Getty Images A man pays his respects at a makeshift memorial in the destroyed gym at the schoolGetty Images

A man pays his respects at a makeshift memorial in the destroyed gym at the school in 2004

Numbers and lies

Last month in Beslan, just three mothers were brought to meet him.

“It was an awful act of terror that took the lives of 334 people,” Mr Putin described their tragedy to them, for the sake of the state TV camera.

“Of that number, 136 were children.”

The mothers are not in vision at that moment, but they surely winced at his mistake.

Because 186 children were killed in Beslan.

It’s a number engrained on the brains of everyone in that town. It’s the one thing you don’t forget.

But Mr Putin didn’t visit Beslan to empathise. The mothers in black were just a prop.

He was using them to make a point.

Two decades ago, he reminded Russians, he had fought and won his war on terror. Now he was battling “neo-Nazis” and a hostile West in Ukraine, and he vowed he would win that war too.

Distortion and lies were already in the 2004 Putin playbook. Then, officials grossly under reported the number of hostages in Beslan.

I arrived in town on the first day of the siege and soon realised there were three times more hostages captive in that school than officials were admitting to.

Every local told us so. But state TV reporters, under instruction, continued to repeat the lie.

People feared that troops were preparing to storm the school, so the authorities were playing down the potential casualty-count.

Getty Images A fireman investigates a gym during the rescue operation at Beslan schoolGetty Images

A fireman investigates a gym during the rescue operation at Beslan school

Lessons for Putin

I’ve often wondered what would happen to a government in a Western democracy after an attack that ended with many more hostages dead than terrorists.

I think it would struggle to survive the inevitable official inquiry, or the next election.

Vladimir Putin didn’t have to worry about either.

In 2017, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Russia had failed in its duty to protect the hostages and used “indiscriminate force” as the siege collapsed. The case was brought by desperate, bereaved mothers, hunting for justice.

But there was no new investigation in Russia itself. No senior officials held to account.

When the three Beslan mothers complained to Mr Putin about that last month, at their meeting, he professed surprise and promised to look into it. He’s had 20 years.

He did address one thing, though, right after the siege.

In 2004, Mr Putin announced he was cancelling direct elections for governors in Russia’s regions, claiming that would help improve security. There was no connection whatsoever to the Beslan attack.

When parliament gathered to vote on the move, opposition politicians picketed the building warning of a creeping dictatorship.

Two decades on, there is no more opposition.

Russia’s governors are still appointed by the Kremlin. Democracy has been crushed.

The one lesson Mr Putin took from the siege of School No. 1 was one about increasing control.



Source link

Related Posts

Norwegian crown princess's son found guilty of two counts of rape

June 15, 2026
0

Marius Borg Høiby, the 29-year-old son of Norway's Crown Princess Mette Marit, has been found guilty of two counts...

Royal Marines board Russian shadow fleet oil tanker in English Channel

June 14, 2026
0

Marines were joined by National Crime Agency officers in the six-hour long operation in the early hours of Sunday....

From war to World Cup – Dzeko’s last dance could be Bosnia’s new beginning

June 13, 2026
0

Dzeko made his international debut in 2007, and now holds the records for the most appearances (148) and most...

  • Lee McGregor: Scot seeks world title in 2025 & Nathaniel Collins bout

    677 shares
    Share 271 Tweet 169
  • Belgian footballer arrested in cocaine investigation

    533 shares
    Share 213 Tweet 133
  • Next to raise prices to help pay for rising wage costs

    531 shares
    Share 212 Tweet 133
  • South Wales Police officers injured, one arrested

    525 shares
    Share 210 Tweet 131
  • Charities to get £15m fund to save surplus farm food

    516 shares
    Share 206 Tweet 129
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest

Lee McGregor: Scot seeks world title in 2025 & Nathaniel Collins bout

January 16, 2025

Belgian footballer arrested in cocaine investigation

January 27, 2025

Next to raise prices to help pay for rising wage costs

January 7, 2025

World Cup 2022: TikTok brings football fever to millions of fans

0

UK economy will get worse before it gets better, warns chancellor

0

One of Central America’s most active volcanoes erupts again

0

Trump may release US-Iran deal before Friday, Vance says

June 16, 2026

What is Helium-3 and could we get it from the moon?

June 16, 2026

Polls open on Thursday for the Makerfield by-election

June 16, 2026

Categories

Top News

Trump may release US-Iran deal before Friday, Vance says

June 16, 2026
0

The US vice-president says the agreement is "about a page and a half" and "very general", meaning many details...

Read more

What is Helium-3 and could we get it from the moon?

June 16, 2026
News

© 2023 GODJ - NEWS CORP - news.godj.com.

Explore NEWS.GODJ.COM

  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Worklife
  • Travel
  • Reel
  • Future
  • More

Follow Us

  • Home Main
  • Video
  • World
  • Top News
  • Business
  • Sport
  • Tech
  • UK
  • In Pictures
  • Health
  • Reality Check
  • Science
  • Entertainment & Arts
  • Login

© 2023 GODJ - NEWS CORP - news.godj.com.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.